Back to Writing

Generalists are a startup's secret weapon

Hiring is built to find specialists, because that's what factories needed and nobody rewrote the process. A ten-person startup needs people who'll cover four jobs at once, and there's no line on a CV for that.

2 min read

Our whole work system is built for specialists, which is a hangover from the Industrial Revolution. Milly Tamati, who founded Generalist World, made this point in Sifted’s Startup Life newsletter and it stuck with me. Assembly lines reward people who do one thing deeply, forever. An early-stage startup is nothing like an assembly line. It needs people who can hold several roles at once and still ship something.

That’s the generalist. Someone who connects things, learns fast, and can drop into whatever is on fire this week.

What to look for

You’re hiring for a particular mix rather than someone who does everything, so think in skill stacks rather than skill lists. Three signals are worth more than a tidy CV:

  • Connecting unrelated problems. Evidence they’ve taken scattered inputs and made something new out of the combination.
  • Speed of learning. Experience is useful; adaptability is the thing you’re buying. Did they teach themselves a tool over a weekend to get a prototype out?
  • Pattern recognition. Can they look at a pile of feature requests and see the MVP inside it?

Interview for it differently

Generalists have non-linear histories, and a standard interview script reads that as a warning sign when it’s the entire point. So test the thing you’re hiring for:

  1. Problem-solving under pressure. “We just lost a key client. What do you do in the first 48 hours?”
  2. Practical range. “How have you got non-technical stakeholders to understand technical debt?”
  3. Lasting impact. “Tell me about a process you built that kept working after you left.”

Red flags

  • Vague impact. No metrics, no specifics. Be wary.
  • Rigid thinking. Generalists have to operate without clear direction, and some people can’t.
  • Blame-shifting. Look for people who own their mistakes and learned something from them.
  • Short-term focus. Quick fixes are tempting; the job is the sustainable version.
  • Tech blindness. Most business problems need more than a technical answer, and the reverse is also true.

Where they hide

Generic job boards are a waste of time here. Look at:

  • Cross-functional roles. Product ops, growth, strategic projects.
  • Early employees at fast-growing startups, who’ve already worn every hat.
  • Side-hustlers building their own tools and systems.
  • Ex-founders, an under-used pool of people who’ve seen most of it go wrong once already.

Set them up properly

Hiring a generalist and then boxing them into a specialist role wastes the thing you hired for. Give them room to work across boundaries and make sure leadership actually agrees with that, because otherwise they’ll spend their time defending the role instead of doing it. Measure them on overall impact and on the systems they improve, rather than on output inside one function.